Home Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in South Carolina for 2024: Home Insurance Quotes South Carolina

Compare the best homeowners insurance companies in South Carolina

Through our research, which involved analyzing average rates from Quadrant Information Services and evaluating various metrics like customer satisfaction scores from the 2023 J.D. Power U.S. Home Insurance Study, we've identified the top homeowners insurance companies in South Carolina. Insurance Tennessee, Central Insurance Quote, and Insurance Georgia are among the best options available. Although only two of these companies offer average rates below the state average of $2,360 per year, the others provide an array of coverage options, digital tools, and unique policy features that make them noteworthy.

If you're searching for the best homeowners insurance in South Carolina, comparing quotes from multiple providers is a smart approach. Starting your search with these five companies may be particularly beneficial.

Insurance Company Ratings and Premiums
Insurance Company J.D. Power Average Monthly Premium Average Annual Premium
Central Insurance Quote 834 / 1,000 $212 $2,541
Insurance South Carolina 790 / 1,000 $222 $2,658
Insurance Georgia 809 / 1,000 $203 $2,442
Insurance Tennessee 829 / 1,000 $147 $1,765
Insurance Alabama Not rated N/A N/A

Premiums are based on $300,000 in dwelling coverage.

Home insurance rates can change frequently, but you can count on us to keep you informed about the most current options.

Insurance South Carolina's Trusted Insurance Industry Expertise

Understanding the complexities of the home insurance market can be challenging. However, Insurance South Carolina's insurance editorial team leveraged our in-depth knowledge to provide readers with the essential information needed to make informed choices when selecting home insurance.

46

Years of industry expertise

122

Carriers evaluated

34.5K

ZIP codes analyzed

1.2M

Data points reviewed

Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in South Carolina by ZIP

Below, you can get personalized Cheap Home insurance quotes for your specific location in South Carolina.

The top 5 home insurance companies in South Carolina

Central Insurance Quote

4.6

Insurance Rating

Avg. full coverage premium

$212/mo

Avg. full coverage premium

$2,541/yr

Customer satisfaction

834/1,000

Overview:

Why Central Insurance Quote made our list: Despite its name, Central Insurance Quote offers more than just auto insurance. This super-regional company provides comprehensive homeowners insurance, featuring options like guaranteed replacement cost coverage, equipment breakdown insurance, and its exclusive Homeowners Plus package. This package includes unique benefits like coverage for food spoilage due to power outages from a covered peril. You can also take advantage of special discounts, such as those for getting a quote in advance, having an automatic backup generator, being mortgage-free, or installing a water shut-off system. However, its mobile app, available on Android and Apple devices, has received fewer stars compared to competitors, which might be a drawback for homeowners who prefer managing their policies online.

Who Central Insurance Quote may be good for: If you're seeking extensive coverage on a budget, Central Insurance Quote's competitive rates and wide array of discounts might be appealing.

Pros

  • Offers unique discounts not available with other insurers
  • The Homeowners Plus package is ideal for those who want extensive coverage without needing to choose individual add-ons

Cons

  • Mobile app features are not as advanced as those of competitors
  • No online quoting; policies must be purchased through independent agents

Central Insurance Quote provides a wide range of optional coverages to meet various personal insurance needs, including:

  • Farm insurance: Offers protection for farming equipment and can cover pollution spills, though availability varies by state.
  • Boat insurance: Provides coverage for boats, jetskis, and other watercraft.
  • Water backup of sewers or drains: Covers repairs for damage to floors, walls, furniture, and electrical systems caused by water backup.

South Carolina City Central Insurance Quote Avg. Annual Premium for $300K Dwelling
Charleston $3,588
Rock Hill $1,687
Mount Pleasant $4,591
North Charleston $3,064
Columbia $1,987
Insurance South Carolina

4.1

Insurance Rating

Avg. full coverage premium

$222/mo

Avg. full coverage premium

$2,658/yr

Customer satisfaction

790/1,000

Overview:

Why Insurance South Carolina made our list: Insurance South Carolina stands out for those seeking a home insurance policy with a wide range of add-ons. The company's comprehensive home insurance offerings can also help you secure essential coverages, such as higher limits for valuable items and options to rebuild with eco-friendly materials after a covered loss. To maximize your savings, consider reaching out to one of Insurance South Carolina’s nearly 700 independent insurance agencies in South Carolina to explore which discounts you may qualify for. However, it’s worth noting that Insurance South Carolina has the third-lowest J.D. Power customer satisfaction rating among the companies we reviewed, scoring significantly below the industry average.

Who Insurance South Carolina may be good for: If you need a policy with extensive customization options, Insurance South Carolina could be a good choice, offering a broader range of add-ons compared to many other insurers.

Pros

  • Offers a unique selection of coverage add-ons to enhance your home insurance policy
  • Local agencies provide in-person support

Cons

  • Below-average performance in J.D. Power’s 2023 Home Insurance Study
  • The mobile app experience may not be as advanced as those of other insurers

Insurance South Carolina is known for its extensive range of insurance products and allows policyholders to personalize their coverage with various endorsements. Some of the optional coverages available include:

  • Jewelry and valuable items coverage: Ideal for protecting high-value items that exceed typical homeowners policy limits, such as fine jewelry, art, and collectibles.
  • Identity fraud coverage: Provides up to $25,000 in reimbursement for expenses incurred while restoring your identity after it's been stolen.
  • Green home coverage: Offers additional protection for the costs of repairing, replacing, or rebuilding using eco-friendly materials following a covered loss.

South Carolina City Insurance South Carolina Avg. Annual Premium for $300K Dwelling
Charleston $3,984
Rock Hill $3,780
Mount Pleasant $7,036
North Charleston $3,414
Columbia $1,319
Insurance North Carolina

4.2

Insurance Rating

Avg. full coverage premium

$203/mo

Avg. full coverage premium

$2,442/yr

Customer satisfaction

809/1,000

Overview:

Why Insurance North Carolina made our list: As the second-largest home insurer in the U.S. by market share, according to the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), Insurance North Carolina is a strong contender for North Carolina homeowners who prefer managing their policies online and accessing a wealth of insurance information. Insurance North Carolina offers a range of unique endorsements, including coverage for yard and garden, sports equipment, musical instruments, and green improvements. However, its J.D. Power customer satisfaction rating, as reported in the 2023 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study, falls below average.

Who Insurance North Carolina may be good for: Insurance North Carolina's average premium in North Carolina is significantly lower compared to other companies we reviewed. It may be worth obtaining a quote to see if they can offer a similar rate for you.

Pros

  • Extensive range of optional coverages to customize your home insurance policy
  • Multiple digital tools, including Digital Locker, to assist with insurance planning

Cons

  • Slightly lower AM Best financial strength rating compared to other major national insurers
  • Below-average ranking for customer service in J.D. Power’s 2023 Home Insurance Study

Insurance North Carolina, a prominent home insurance provider, offers more than just basic coverage, including options tailored to specific needs:

  • Personal articles coverage: Protects high-value items like jewelry, antiques, or electronics against loss or damage.
  • Identity restoration coverage: Provides support and covers expenses for restoring your identity if it's stolen or compromised in the digital age.
  • Boat insurance: Covers physical damage to your boat and liability if you are responsible for damages to someone else's property.

South Carolina City Insurance North Carolina Avg. Annual Premium for $300K Dwelling
Charleston $3,621
Rock Hill $1,406
Mount Pleasant $4,355
North Charleston $4,093
Columbia $1,601

Insurance Tennessee

4.2

Insurance Rating

Avg. full coverage premium

$147/mo

Avg. full coverage premium

$1,765/yr

Customer satisfaction

829/1,000

Overview:

Why Insurance Tennessee made our list: Insurance Tennessee is a strong option for homeowners who prioritize customer service and prefer working directly with a live agent. The company has established a network of local agents across South Carolina who can help with homeowners insurance as well as other insurance products offered by Insurance Tennessee. Although Insurance Tennessee offers various coverage options to customize your home insurance policy, its range of discounts is somewhat limited.

Who Insurance Tennessee may be good for: If personalized service and high customer satisfaction are important to you, Insurance Tennessee may be a good choice. The company's high ranking with J.D. Power suggests a strong emphasis on customer care, and it may go the extra mile to ensure that its policyholders are satisfied.

Pros

  • Offers optional coverage to customize your home insurance policy to suit your needs
  • Extensive network of local agencies for face-to-face service

Cons

  • Fewer discount options compared to some competitors
  • Average premiums are slightly above the state average

Insurance Tennessee provides a wide range of policy options, allowing for customized coverage to meet specific needs. Some of the optional coverages available include:

  • Personal articles coverage: Additional protection for valuable items such as jewelry, collectibles, cameras, and more.
  • Farm and ranch coverage: Extra protection for farm-related structures, homes, and other property.
  • Identity restoration coverage: Covers losses related to fraud, cyber extortion, and other cybersecurity incidents that might affect the policyholder financially.

South Carolina City Insurance Tennessee Avg. Annual Premium for $300K Dwelling
Charleston $1,944
Rock Hill $1,647
Mount Pleasant $2,112
North Charleston $1,948
Columbia $1,641

Insurance Alabama

N/A

Insurance Rating

Avg. full coverage premium

N/A

Avg. full coverage premium

N/A

Customer satisfaction

Not Rated

Overview:

Why Insurance Alabama made our list: Insurance Alabama could be a solid choice for South Carolina homeowners with high-value properties. The company offers three distinct tiers of homeowners insurance: Executive Homeowner, Executive Capstone, and Executive Classic. The Executive Homeowner plan caters to any home value, while the Executive Classic is designed for homes valued at $500,000 and above, and the Executive Capstone is for properties worth $1 million and up. Unfortunately, Insurance Alabama was not rated by J.D. Power for customer service.

Who Insurance Alabama may be good for: Homeowners in South Carolina with properties valued at $500K or more might find Insurance Alabama appealing. The company has extensive experience with high-value homes and understands the specialized coverage these properties require.

Pros

  • Tiered insurance plans accommodate a broad range of home values
  • Local independent agencies offer personalized, in-person service

Cons

  • Fewer advertised discounts compared to many competitors
  • Lack of a J.D. Power customer satisfaction rating due to its smaller market presence

Insurance Alabama offers a variety of insurance options tailored to meet diverse needs. Key additional coverage types include:

  • Personal articles coverage: Also known as scheduled personal property coverage, this insurance is designed to protect high-value items like fine jewelry, antiques, and collectibles.
  • Boat insurance: Covers boats and personal watercraft, whether over or under 20 feet in length.
  • Personal cyber protection: Provides financial coverage and expert support for managing cyber threats such as identity theft, online fraud, and data breaches.

South Carolina City Insurance Alabama Avg. Annual Premium for $300K Dwelling
Charleston N/A
Rock Hill N/A
Mount Pleasant N/A
North Charleston N/A
Columbia N/A

Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in South Carolina by ZIP

Below, you can get personalized Cheap Home insurance quotes for your specific location in South Carolina.

How the Best Home Insurance Companies in South Carolina Were Selected by Insurance South Carolina

Insurance South Carolina’s insurance team selected the top homeowners insurance providers in South Carolina by evaluating several critical factors. These factors included analyzing average premiums from Quadrant Information Services, assessing the range of coverage options, available discounts, and mobile app functionality. Additionally, we reviewed third-party industry ratings for customer service and financial stability.

The performance of each insurance company across these categories was then consolidated into an Insurance South Carolina Score. This score provides a comprehensive view of each company, allowing you to compare them more effectively. A higher score indicates better performance across the assessed metrics, with the highest possible score being 5 out of 5.

Cheapest Home Insurance South Carolina: Top Companies for Affordable Coverage

When seeking affordable home insurance in South Carolina, exploring a range of options is crucial. The table below highlights some of the most competitively priced home insurance providers in the state. This selection, based on factors such as coverage options and average costs, is intended to help homeowners find a balance between cost and dependable coverage. Although these options may not be ideal for every individual's needs, they provide a solid starting point for those focused on budget-friendly insurance solutions.

Insurance Premium Comparison
Carrier Monthly Premium for $300K Coverage Annual Premium for $300K Coverage Savings vs. State Average for $300K Coverage
Insurance North Carolina $126 $1,509 -$851
Insurance Tennessee $147 $1,765 -$595
UPC $191 $2,293 -$67
Insurance Georgia $203 $2,442 +$82
Central Insurance Quote $212 $2,541 +$181

Insurance rates can vary frequently, but Insurance South Carolina is committed to providing the latest available options to help you make an informed decision.

How to Get Cheap South Carolina Home Insurance

Even if you don't have a mortgage, securing a homeowner’s policy is a smart move to safeguard your finances against covered disasters. To avoid overpaying for home insurance, it’s essential to have a strategy when shopping for a new policy. Here are some effective steps to help you find affordable homeowners insurance in South Carolina:

  1. Evaluate Your Home: Determine the amount of dwelling coverage you need to rebuild your home if necessary, keeping in mind that replacement costs can differ significantly from your home’s market value. Also, consider the amount of liability coverage you might require. Your insurer will need details about your home, such as the age of your roof and its proximity to a fire station.
  2. Check Company Websites: Review the websites of insurance companies you’re interested in. Look for answers to your questions and check if they list discounts and coverage options.
  3. Understand Company Practices: If you prefer handling your insurance electronically, verify if the company offers a digital app. Ensure you can perform essential tasks such as making payments and filing claims online or through a smartphone app. Alternatively, if you prefer face-to-face interactions, find out if the companies have local agents.
  4. Collect Quotes: Insurance rates are personalized, and coverage options and discounts can vary between companies. Therefore, it’s advisable to obtain free quotes from several home insurance providers. When comparing quotes, ensure you request the same types and amounts of coverage from each company for accurate comparisons. Additionally, review each company's discount offerings to see if you qualify for any.

Best Home Insurance Discounts in South Carolina

To secure the most affordable home insurance policy, leveraging discounts is crucial. Most insurers provide various discounts that can significantly reduce your premium, provided you meet the qualifications. Many of these discounts are straightforward to obtain. Here are some common discounts available in South Carolina:

Bundling.
Protective Devices.
Claims-Free.
Home Renovation.
Gated Community.

How Much is Home Insurance in South Carolina?

Homeowners in South Carolina typically pay an average of $2,360 per year for $300K of dwelling coverage. This figure is 4% lower than the national average of $2,270, which is good news for residents. Additionally, it’s lower compared to neighbouring states: Georgia homeowners average $1,965 annually, while North Carolina residents pay about $2,513 for similar coverage.

The relatively lower cost in South Carolina may be attributed to reduced construction costs, leading to cheaper rebuilding expenses. Coastal areas might experience higher rates due to the risk of tropical cyclones, but those living inland are likely to enjoy lower insurance rates.

Cheap Home Insurance Quotes in South Carolina by ZIP

Below, you can get personalized Cheap Home insurance quotes for your specific location in South Carolina.

South Carolina Homeowners Insurance Rates by City

Homeowners insurance costs in South Carolina can differ greatly depending on the city where you live. Factors such as local weather conditions, crime rates, and the overall cost of living can impact premium rates. The following data provides a detailed look at how insurance rates vary across different cities in South Carolina. This information can help both current and prospective homeowners better understand potential insurance costs.

Home Insurance Rates in South Carolina by City

Rates are based on $300,000 in dwelling coverage. Insurance costs are subject to frequent changes, so be sure to check the latest information for the most accurate rates.

What Does Home Insurance Cover in South Carolina?

A typical HO-3 home insurance policy in South Carolina provides broad protection against various unforeseen events. This policy generally covers the main dwelling, additional structures on the property, personal belongings, liability, and extra living expenses. For the dwelling and other structures, an HO-3 policy offers open perils coverage, meaning it covers all risks unless explicitly excluded. However, personal property coverage under this policy is based on named perils.

In South Carolina, certain perils are particularly relevant due to the state's geographical and climatic conditions:

While these are some of the most pertinent perils for South Carolina homeowners, it's important to review your policy thoroughly to understand the full scope of coverage. The cost of home insurance in South Carolina can vary based on factors such as location and specific risks covered. Comparing options from different providers can help you find the best coverage to meet your needs and budget.

Additional Home Insurance Coverage Types in South Carolina

When seeking homeowners insurance quotes in South Carolina, you'll find that essential coverage types like dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses are standard. However, for added protection beyond the basics, consider these optional coverage types:

Consulting with a licensed insurance agent can be beneficial. A local agent can provide personalized advice to help you select the appropriate coverage that aligns with your budget and needs.

Common Home Insurance Issues in South Carolina

Homeowners in South Carolina frequently encounter specific challenges when obtaining home insurance due to the state's diverse geography and climate. These challenges include:

Frequently Asked Questions

While South Carolina does not mandate homeowners insurance, mortgage lenders typically require it to protect both the lender's and homeowner’s financial interests. Even if you own your home outright, maintaining a homeowners insurance policy is advisable. Without insurance, you would be responsible for covering any property losses out of pocket. Additionally, homeowners are liable for injuries that occur on their property and damage to personal belongings. Therefore, experts generally recommend having homeowners insurance, regardless of whether you have a mortgage.

The most affordable homeowners insurance varies based on personal factors. Your annual premium can be influenced by aspects such as your ZIP code, claims history, the age and value of your home, the age of your roof, your credit-based insurance score, proximity to a fire station, and the coverage and deductible options you choose. It’s beneficial to shop around and obtain multiple quotes to compare prices and coverage options from different insurers.

To reduce your home insurance costs, start by comparing rates from different providers. Each insurer uses its own rating system, so the same coverage can vary in price between companies. Additionally, take advantage of available discounts, such as those for home alarm systems or a claims-free history. Increasing your deductible can also lower your premium, but be mindful that you will need to cover more out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim, so choose a deductible amount that suits your financial situation.

Most standard homeowners policies in South Carolina include coverage for hurricane wind damage, though you may face a separate windstorm deductible, which can range from 1% to 5% of your dwelling limit. For flood damage caused by hurricanes, you will need a separate flood insurance policy. Flood coverage can be obtained through the NFIP, private insurers, or as an endorsement to your existing homeowners policy.

An insurance company can cancel your policy at any time during its term or choose not to renew it when it expires. Common reasons for policy cancellation include misrepresentation on your application, insolvency of the insurer, or issues discovered during an inspection, such as structural problems or an ineligible pet. If your policy is canceled, the insurer must provide written notice 30 days prior to the cancellation or nonrenewal date, detailing the reason for the action. To find a new policy, consider comparing offerings, obtaining multiple quotes, and reviewing third-party ratings.